Humidity and gravimetric equivalency adjustments for nephelometer-based particulate matter measurements of emissions from solid biomass fuel use in cookstoves. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2014 Jun 19;11(6):6400-16. doi: 10.3390/ijerph110606400.

Soneja S, et al.

Great uncertainty exists around indoor biomass burning exposure-disease relationships due to lack of detailed exposure data in large health outcome studies. Passive nephelometers can be used to estimate high particulate matter (PM) concentrations during cooking in low resource environments. Since passive nephelometers do not have a collection filter they are not subject to sampler overload. Nephelometric concentration readings can be biased due to particle growth in high humid environments and differences in compositional and size dependent aerosol characteristics.

This paper explores relative humidity (RH) and gravimetric equivalency adjustment approaches to be used for the pDR-1000 used to assess indoor PM concentrations for a cookstove intervention trial in Nepal. Three approaches to humidity adjustment performed equivalently (similar root mean squared error). For gravimetric conversion, the new linear regression equation with log-transformed variables performed better than the traditional linear equation. In addition, gravimetric conversion equations utilizing a spline or quadratic term were examined.

We propose a humidity adjustment equation encompassing the entire RH range instead of adjusting for RH above an arbitrary 60% threshold. Furthermore, we propose new integrated RH and gravimetric conversion methods because they have one response variable (gravimetric PM2.5 concentration), do not contain an RH threshold, and is straightforward.

Issue 150 | June 20, 2014 | Focus on Gender Mainstreaming and Clean Cookstoves

This issue of WASHplus Weekly includes presentations, papers, and reports on “gender mainstreaming” – how to best empower women through cooking solutions and strategies for actively engaging women in the clean stove and fuel value chains.

PAPERS

The Kaleidoscope of Cooking—Understanding Cooking Behaviour and Stove Preferences in Rural India, 2014. GIZ. (Link)
This report identifies cooking technologies suitable for users living in diverse geographical and socio-economic backgrounds. It also includes suggestions from rural cooks on improving existing cookstoves to better meet their cooking requirements.

Gender Differences in Preferences, Intra-Household Externalities, and Low Demand for Improved Cookstoves, 2013. G Miller, National Bureau of Economic Research. (Link)
This paper explores whether public policy will be able to exploit gender differences in preferences to promote cooking technology adoption absent broader social change.

Hivos Policy Guidelines: Gender Mainstreaming in Hivos’ Domestic Biogas and Improved Cook Stove Programmes, 2013. E Nijland. (Link)
This paper contributes to the discussion on a gender mainstreaming policy and strategy for Hivos’ programs on renewable energy by focusing on two key sub-programs: improved cookstoves and domestic biogas.

REPORTS

Scaling Adoption of Clean Cooking Solutions through Women’s Empowerment: A Resource Guide, 2013. Global Alliance for Clean Cookstoves and UK Department for International Development (DFID). (Link)
The guide is meant for a wide variety of sector stakeholders to increase their understanding of why women have a critical role to play and how to ensure they are included in each segment of the clean cooking value chain.

[click to continue…]

Bookmark and Share

Join the C4D forum for Clean Stove Initative (CSI) – an invitation from the World Bank!

If you are looking for good resources to learn about best practices on clean cooking and heating solutions, and further collaborate with peers to discuss about the topic, you should check out the platform recently launched by World Bank’s CSI. Please check out more information and join us here:
https://collaboration.worldbank.org/groups/clean-cooking-and-heating-solutions

A search on Science Direct for studies published so far in June on cookstoves retrieved the 4 studies below:

S.M. O’Shaughnessy, M.J. Deasy, J.V. Doyle, A.J. Robinson, Field trial testing of an electricity-producing portable biomass cooking stove in rural MalawiEnergy for Sustainable Development, Volume 20, June 2014, Pages 1-10, ISSN 0973-0826, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.esd.2014.01.009

A novel off-grid electricity-producing device has been designed for integration with biomass-fuelled improved cooking stoves commonly in use in the developing world. The device operates on the thermoelectric principle whereby small amounts of electricity can be produced in response to a temperature difference across a thermoelectric generator, or TEG. The energy produced by the integrated generator can be used for direct charging or stored in a rechargeable lithium–iron-phosphate (LiFePo4) battery. The generator is equipped with a standard USB output which allows the user to charge a variety of 5 Volt appliances. Five technology demonstrator electricity generating stoves have been integrated with locally produced clay cooking stoves in the Balaka District of Malawi, Africa. This study details the results from an 80-day field trial of the devices. The data reveals that the stoves are in use for a greater time than was anticipated. The data also indicates that the generators perform adequately in the field and provide the user with the ability to charge LED lights and mobile phones from the generator stoves every day if necessary.

Lalisa A. Duguma, Peter A. Minang, Olivia E. Freeman, Herbert Hager, System wide impacts of fuel usage patterns in the Ethiopian highlands: Potentials for breaking the negative reinforcing feedback cycles, Energy for Sustainable Development, Volume 20, June 2014, Pages 77-85, ISSN 0973-0826, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.esd.2014.03.004

Due to scarcity of firewood, farmers in rural Ethiopia are forced to use cattle dung as a complementary energy source. By looking at patterns of firewood and cattle dung use for energy generation and their implications for food crop production, forest regeneration and community level emission reduction potentials, this study explores system interactions using a community living next to the Menagesha Suba state forest in Ethiopia as a case study. Mixed methods were used including household surveys, nutrient content analyses of firewood and cattle dung, and calculations of fuel and emission reductions for four cooking energy efficiency scenarios. It was found that the community and surrounding environment is stuck in a negative feedback cycle. Therefore shifts in current practices and systems are needed to break this cycle, for example by enhancing firewood supply, improving soil fertility, improving energy efficiency and enabling access to carbon financing for emissions reduced.

Pia Piroschka Otte, A (new) cultural turn toward solar cooking—Evidence from six case studies across India and Burkina Faso, Energy Research & Social Science, Volume 2, June 2014, Pages 49-58, ISSN 2214-6296, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.erss.2014.04.006.

Solar cooking can generally be described as a way to use the sun’s energy for cooking. Despite its multiple benefits as a clean, modular, simple source of energy, the implementation of solar cookers is not as widespread as one would hope. In the literature it is argued that solar cookers are not adopted because they are often considered to be culturally disruptive. This paper shines a new light on the cultural dynamics of cooking by showcasing the social acceptance of solar cookers. Six cases are presented from two different countries, Burkina Faso and India where a particular type of solar cooker (Scheffler reflectors) was installed among bakeries, shea nut butter producers, and steam kitchens. These cases demonstrate how cultural factors can be adoption-enhancing or limiting in different contexts. In essence, the paper finds that solar cookers are successfully implemented where they conform to underlying cultural factors. The study concludes that by implementing solar cookers as part of an existing socio-cultural framework, solar cookers move away from an image of a mere foreign technology to an integrated part of the target society.

Dale T. Manning, J. Edward Taylor, Migration and fuel use in rural Mexico, Ecological Economics, Volume 102, June 2014, Pages 126-136, ISSN 0921-8009, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolecon.2014.03.012

Many households in developing countries rely on renewable natural resources as their main source of energy. Collecting and burning firewood requires a considerable amount of time, has negative health consequences, and can cause deforestation and depletion of local resources if forests are not properly managed. A transition from traditional to modern fuels can benefit households by reducing these negative effects. Migration, a quintessential feature of development, may facilitate this transition, but its impacts on fuel choice are theoretically ambiguous. It can reduce the household labor available for firewood collection and provide cash to purchase substitutes; however, it has an income effect that changes the demand for home-cooked food and energy to cook it. Firewood or gas could be used to meet the increase in energy demand. To resolve this theoretical ambiguity, we use an instrumental-variables method with household panel data from rural Mexico and investigate the impact of Mexico-to-US migration and remittances on gas expenditures and household labor allocated to firewood collection. Sending a migrant to the United States causes a significant decrease in reliance on firewood collection and an increase in both stove and gas purchases. These findings have potentially far-reaching environmental implications as labor moves off the farm.

Household Cooking Fuel Choice and Adoption of Improved Cookstoves in Developing Countries: A Review, 2014.

Sunil Malla; Govinda R Timilsina. World Bank.

Improving access to affordable and reliable energy services for cooking is essential for developing countries in reducing adverse human health and environmental impacts hitherto caused by burning of traditional biomass. This paper reviews empirical studies that analyze choices of fuel and adoption of improved stoves for cooking in countries where biomass is still the predominant cooking fuel.

The review highlights the wide range of factors that influence households’ cooking fuel choices and adoption of improved stoves, including socioeconomic (access and availability, collection costs and fuel prices, household income, education and awareness), behavioral (food tastes, lifestyle), and cultural and external factors (indoor air pollution, government policies).

The paper also summarizes the evidence on the significant adverse health impacts from exposure to indoor smoke, especially among women and young children. In low-income households, perceived health benefits of adopting improved stoves and financial benefits from fuel savings tend to be outweighed by the costs of improved stoves, even after accounting for the opportunity cost of time spent collecting biomass fuel. The paper identifies knowledge and evidence gaps on the success of policies and programs designed to scale up the adoption of improved cookstoves.

 

Does household air pollution from cooking fires affect infant neurodevelopment? Developing methods in the NACER pilot study in rural Guatemala. The Lancet, May 2014.

Lisa M Thompson, Guinevere Valencia-Moscoso, Renée Asteria Peñaloza, Anaité Díaz Artiga, Eduardo Canúz, Kirk R Smith, S Katharine Hammond.

Background: Worldwide, 3 billion people are exposed to household air pollution from cooking fires. One of the top two risk factors among neonates, household air pollution greatly affects neonatal morbidity and mortality. In low-resource countries, neurodevelopmental impairments are often not identified during the neonatal period, leading to permanent disability. No published studies have examined the effect of household air pollution exposures on neurodevelopmental impairments in infants. The NACER study in rural Guatemala aims to measure personal exposures to household air pollution during pregnancy and infancy and to train birth attendants to collect standardised measures of infant neurodevelopment.

Methods: Guatemalan indigenous women from rural communities were recruited from a health centre at less than 20 weeks’ gestation and received prenatal health exams at less than 20 weeks, 24–28 weeks, and 32–36 weeks. The study was conducted between January, 2012, and December, 2013. Home visits were made three times during pregnancy to monitor prenatal exposures to carbon monoxide (particulate matter; PM2·5) and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons. Home visits were made within 48 h of birth and at 1, 3, 6, 9, and 12 months to assess household air pollution exposures and measure infant neurodevelopment with a validated 27-item instrument (Rapid Neurodevelopmental Assessment) developed in Bangladesh for use with semi-skilled health workers and adapted in Guatemala for use with traditional birth attendants. We report on household air pollution and results from Rapid Neurodevelopmental Assessment from the prenatal and neonatal periods.

Findings: 37 pregnant women were enrolled and there were 31 liveborn infants. Gestational age was confirmed by fetal ultrasound (mean 15·2 weeks, range 7–20·1). Five (11%) households used open fires for cooking, whereas 33 (89%) used deteriorated chimney stoves. Mean 15-min maximum exposure to carbon monoxide were 16·9 parts per million (ppm, SD 12·4) during the prenatal period and 13·3 ppm (SD 23·4) during the neonatal. Mean 48-h PM2·5 concentrations were 130·2 µg/m³ (SD 65·3) during pregnancy and 63·8 µg/m³ (SD 17·3) during the neonatal period. 27% of infants were low birthweight (<2500 g) and 8% were preterm (<37 weeks). Of neonates, moderate/severe neurodevelopmental impairments, as defined by the Rapid Neurodevelopmental Assessment cutoff points, were identified in eight domains: fine motor (n=4, 13%), gross motor (10, 32%), speech (5, 16%), cognition (5, 16%), behaviour (4,13%), vision (1, 3%), hearing (6, 19%), and primitive reflexes (7, 23%).

Interpretation: Maternal exposures to household air pollution were higher than were neonatal exposures, but both were higher than WHO recommended guidelines. Low birthweight and moderate/severe neurodevelopmental impairment were high. Pilot data will be used to develop a future, randomised stove intervention study to measure the effect of reduced exposures to household air pollution on low birthweight, preterm delivery, and infant neurodevelopmental impairment.

Tanzania – Cost saving ($410/household/year) and reducing deforestation through energy saving stoves, Kiroka village, Morogoro, 2014. FAO.

About 99% households (HHs) in Kiroka village depend for cooking on firewood, which is now becoming a scarce and expensive resource due to population growth, which has led to agricultural land expansion involving deforestation – and an increased need for firewood. These households still cook using the traditional three-stone open fire hearths, which require huge loads of firewood to function and are very inefficient – reportedly with a heat loss of more than 80%. Dependence on firewood marginalizes local women and girls in the community, as they are burdened with collecting or paying for expensive firewood and cooking over inefficient and smoky traditional stoves. By introducing energy saving stoves that efficiently burn wood, reduce heat wastage and amounts of smoke, the project is improving forest conservation, soil and water protection, women’s health and saving to families money they had needed to buy wood.

Together with producers, retailers, testing agencies and the government, SNV Netherlands Development Organisation and ARMI are developing the market for cookstoves in Laos and improving women’s livelihoods.

Our goal is to produce 100,000 stoves by 2016, which saves more than 10 million kg of charcoal or 32 million kg of wood. The reduction is equal to the greenhouse gas emissions of 20,000 people flying from Vientiane to Amsterdam
and back.

The programme has developed and promotes the Tao Payat stove that uses up to 20% less wood and charcoal than traditional stoves (such as the Tao Lai and Tao Dam). It produces less smoke and improves the health of thousands of women who work in Lao kitchens.

SNV is a founding member of the Global Alliance of Clean Cookstoves.

Join the Clean Cookstove Community on Linkedin

This Community is facilitated by the USAID WASHplus project. We hope this Community will serve as a crowdsourcing platform to share information and collaborate on issues/problems that are faced by researchers and practitioners. We welcome your comments and participation.

Can carbon revenues help transform household energy markets? A scoping study with cookstove programmes in India and Kenya, 2014.

Authors, Fiona Lambe, et al. Stockholm Environment Institute.

Little research has been done on how cookstove projects are using carbon finance. In order to address this gap, we conducted an in-depth review of the project design documents (PDDs) for 75 carbon-financed cookstove projects in India and Kenya. We also interviewed 49 stakeholders along the value chain, including cookstove project implementers (both carbon-financed and not), households, NGOs and cookstove and carbon market experts. A consensus is emerging among policy-makers and donors that a market-based approach is needed to scale up cookstove initiatives and ensure their long-term sustainability.